| 1980 CTA Drama Festival |
| Count Dracula |
| Best Director: | Lyle W. Pearsons |
| Best Supporting Actor: | Gordon Glover |
|
| 1981 CTA Drama Festival |
| The Chalk Garden |
| Best Connecticut Show |
| Best Director: | Waldo Goodermote |
| Best Actress: | Betty Williams |
| Best Set Design: | Waldo Goodermote |
| Best Costumes (HM): | Virginia Keir |
|
| 1982 CTA Drama Festival |
| The Glass Menagerie |
| Best Show Of Festival |
| Best Connecticut Show |
| Best Director: | Waldo Goodermote |
| Best Actress (HM): | Betty Williams |
| Best Actor (HM): | Lyle W. Pearsons |
| Best Set Design: | Waldo Goodermote |
|
| 1983 NETC |
| Tartuffe |
| Best Show, runner-up |
| Best Connecticut Show |
| Best Costumes: | Nadine Glover |
| Best Supporting Actress: | Kelly Seip |
| Best Supporting Actress (HM): | Mary K. Makoski |
|
| 1984 ACT/CONN Drama Festival |
| Vanities |
| Best Show, State Award |
| Best Director: | Denise Boutin |
| Best Actres (HM): | Diane Novak |
| Best Costumes: | Nadine Glover |
| Best Set Design: | Lyle W. Pearsons |
| Stage Managers' Award |
|
| 1985 ACT/CONN Drama Festival |
| Talley's Folly |
| Best Production, runner-up |
| Best Actor: | Konrad Rogowski |
| Best Director (HM): | Konrad Rogowski |
| Best Set Design (HM): | Craig Parker & Konrad Rogowski |
| Judges' Special Award |
| Best Lighting Design: | Jerry Zalewski |
|
| 1986 ACT/CONN Drama Festival |
| Gin Game |
| Best Director: | Lyle W. Pearsons |
| Best Set Design: | Konrad Rogowski (HM) |
| Best Actress: | Kelly Seip |
| Best Actor (HM): | John Howland |
|
|
| 1987 ACT/CONN Drama Festival |
| A Jury Of Her Peers |
| Best Set Design: | Lyle W. Pearsons |
| Best Costumes: | Sue Pearsons |
| Best Director (HM): | Lyle W. Pearsons |
| Stage Managers' Award |
|
| 1988 ACT/CONN Drama Festival |
| Sorry, Wrong Number |
| Best Show, State Award |
| Best Director: | Lyle W. Perasons |
| Best Actress (HM): | Mary K. Makoski |
| Best Costumes: | Lisa Dieli Parker |
| Best Set Design: | Lyle W. Pearsons |
|
| 1989 ACT/CONN Drama Festival |
| Dr. Jekyll & Mr. Hyde |
| Best Ensemble |
| Best Director (HM): | Lyle Pearsons |
| Best Actress: | Margie Secora |
| Best Supporting Actress: | Kelly Seip |
| Best Supporting Actor: | Roger Ochs |
| Best Supporting Actor (HM): | George Chartier |
| Special Award, Artistic Endeavor: | Marcy Secora |
| Special Award, Lighting Design: | Jerry Zalewski |
| Special Award, Sound: | Dave Overson |
| Set Design (HM): | Bob McNerny |
| Best Costume Design: | Margie Secora |
|
| 1990 ACT/CONN Drama Festival |
| Being of Sound Mind |
| Best Production, State Award |
| Best Actress (HM): | Lisa Parker |
| Best Supporting Actress: | Kelly Seip |
| Best Set Design (HM): | Konrad Rogowski |
| Best Director: | Konrad Rogowski |
| Stage Managers' Award |
|
| 1991 ACT/CONN Drama Festival |
| The Audition |
| Best Production, Runner-Up |
| Best Ensemble |
| Best Director: | Margie Secora |
| Best Actor: | Konrad Rogowski (HM) |
| Best Actress: | Lisa Parker |
| Best Set Design: | Owen Hedden &
Lyle W. Pearsons |
| Special Award, Sound: | Walt Alcutt |
|
| 1992 ACT/CONN Drama Festival |
| The Nightingale and Not the Lark |
| Best Supporting Actress: | Karen Balaska |
| Best Costume Design: | Kelly Seip (HM) |
| Best Set Design: | Roger Ochs (HM) |
| Stage Managers' Award |
|
| 1993 ACT/CONN Drama Festival |
| Dark Lady |
| Best Production, Runner-Up |
| Best Actress: | Margie Secora |
| Best Supporting Actress: | Susan Caplan |
| Best Costume Design: | Margie Secora |
| Best Set Design: | Lyle W. Pearsons |
| Special Award, Sound: | Walt Alcutt |
|
| 1994 ACT/CONN Drama Festival |
| I'm Not Rappaport |
| Best Ensemble, Runner-Up |
| Best Supporting Actor: | Paul Gessay (HM) |
| Best Supporting Actress: | Kelly Seip |
| Special Award: | Best Make-Up |
|
| 1995 ACT/CONN Drama Festival |
| The Temp |
| Best Production, Runner-Up |
| Best Director: | Kelly Seip |
| Best Actor: | Scott Grumling |
| Best Supporting Actress: | Amy Heft (HM) |
| Stage Managers' Award |
|
| 1996 ACT/CONN Drama Festival |
| Zoo Story |
| Best Production, Runner-Up |
| Best Ensemble, (HM) |
|
| 1998 CTA Drama Festival |
| The Midlife Crisis of Dionysus |
| Best Production |
| Best Ensemble |
| Outstanding Director: | Kelly Seip |
| Outstanding Performance: | Chris Daly |
| Outstanding Set Design: | Kelly Seip |
|
| 1998 AACT New England Regional Festival |
| Best Backstage Ensemble |
|
| 2002 AACT/Conn Festival |
| The Madwoman of Chaillot |
| Outstanding Performance: | Brad Huskinson |
| Best Set Décor: | The Suffield Players |
|
| 2009 NERF/AACT Regional Festival
|
| Morning's at Seven
|
| Best Supporting Actor: | Konrad Rogowski |
| Best Supporting Actress: | Karen Balaska |
|
| 2013 Massachusetts Critics Circle
|
| Lifetime Achievement: | Konrad Rogowski |
| Best Play: | As You Like It |
| Best Ensemble: | As You Like It |
| Best Director: | Chris Rohmann, As You Like It |
| Best Actor: | Robert Lunde, As You Like It |
| Best Set Design: | Konrad Rogowski & Kelly Seip, As You Like It |
| Best Costume Design: | Jeffrey Flood, As You Like It |
| Best Featured Actor: | Steve Wandzy, Deathtrap |
| Best Featured Actress: | Mary Fernandez-Sierra, Deathtrap |
|
| 2016 Massachusetts Critics Circle
|
| Best Play: | Night Sky |
| Best Ensemble, Play: | The 39 Steps |
| Best Director: | Chris Rohmann, Night Sky |
| Best Supporting Actor, Play: | Shaun O'Keefe, Night Sky |
| Best Costume Design: | Dawn McKay, The 39 Steps |
|
| 2017 Massachusetts Critics Circle
|
| Best Play: | Five Women Wearing The Same Dress |
| Best Ensemble, Play: | Chapter Two |
| Best Featured Actress, Play: | Lisa Parker, Chapter Two |
| Best Set Design: | Konrad Rogowski & Kelly Seip, Chapter Two |
